Left highly unsatisfied... if any one reads this, DON'T GO HERE. My family and I spent nearly $200 for worse service than any other restaurant in the keys. Go ANYWHERE else than here. Even a Wendy's is better than this shoddy joint.
Loved the place. My husband was impressed. We used to go to the one that was there previously and this is so much lighter and clean and high ceilings. One sentence LOVED IT!
AVOID, AVOID, AVOID.
Great key lime pie. Horrible mussels. Horrible paella. 99% percent of food there was awful. Ice cream machine looked dirty. SOOO OVERPRICED! The buffet food sucks... it is clean other then the ice cream machine. The flan is good. Mac n cheese there is pretty good. Rice and beans is also okay. Paella is crunchy and weird. Mussels have a strange taste with rubbery texture. Many mussels were closed, meaning they were old. The pizza was pretty good. The crab cakes have no crab inside. AGAIN WAY TOO EXPENSIVE TO GET JUNK!!! Horrible food. The service was good. No wait. Worst restaurant ever! The food is the quality of a school cafeteria.
Excellent option as a sea food restaurant in the area. Clean, all you can eat buffet, it has few options if you don't eat sea food. Also has dessert included. It has a nice ocean view if you seat close to the window. Little pricy though.
OK, so who is it? Who was supposed to be our server the whole time? Where are they? There were 2 other servers just rolling silverware in cloth napkins... Servers didn't even care about any of us.
Poor food selection, lack of variety. Over fried wings, and basic pizza. Crab cakes didn't seem to have crab in it. Crab legs were okay, but nobody gave us any claw crackers.. I get better service at McDonald's at 2AM..... I would prefer Golden Coral over this garbage place. This place is nothing special in particular.. waited forever to get the check to leave. Requested the check from a server, and was met with "I'm not your server."
The.Best.Seafood.Buffet anywhere! I love this place! I loved it before it closed for renovations, and love it more now! So glad it survived Hurricane Irma and is as great as ever!
At $34.95 per person.. we would've expected a slightly more exquisite experience. No server came to ask us what we wanted to drink... Flagged down a bus boy to find a server to get us water. Didn't get to order drinks until a random server stopped by, about 30 minutes into our meal...
It looked nice, but don't judge a book by its cover...
POOR SERVICE, LACK OF QUALITY FOOD VARIETY, EXPENSIVE PRICE POINTS...
We feel robbed of a good time. Too expensive, non-existent service, lack of diverse food.
Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet is a US Bar based in Islamorada, Florida. Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet is located at 83413 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, USA.
Please contact with Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.
Find Bar in Islamorada